[Suggestion] Config option for chunkloading only when player is on

import_user_oitsjustjose_95mQ commented

2016-07-28 02:01:07 +00:00

(Migrated from git.oitsjustjose.com)

Please add a config to only allow chunkloading to work when the player is online. It'd really help laggy servers with many chunkloaders.

import_user_oitsjustjose_95mQ commented

2016-07-28 02:17:24 +00:00

(Migrated from git.oitsjustjose.com)

assigned to @oitsjustjose

assigned to `@oitsjustjose`

import_user_oitsjustjose_95mQ commented

2016-07-28 02:19:45 +00:00

(Migrated from git.oitsjustjose.com)

Hmmmmmmmmmm.... I'll have to look into this. Chunk Loaders should be restricted in other ways perhaps, like allowing only a server OP to place them (configurable) instead of limiting one to only work with online players.

I only suggest other solutions because this solution directly is going to be incredibly difficult. I'd have to not only track when players log off and log on, I'd have to find a way to track where they've placed chunk loaders, invalidate the loaders when they leave AND validate them when they join.

Let me know your thoughts on limiting chunk loaders on SMP to only being placed by Operators (configurable, like I said) as a way to reduce chunk loading lag.

Hmmmmmmmmmm.... I'll have to look into this. Chunk Loaders should be restricted in other ways perhaps, like allowing only a server OP to place them (configurable) instead of limiting one to only work with online players. I only suggest other solutions because this solution directly is going to be incredibly difficult. I'd have to not only track when players log off and log on, I'd have to find a way to track where they've placed chunk loaders, invalidate the loaders when they leave AND validate them when they join. Let me know your thoughts on limiting chunk loaders on SMP to only being placed by Operators (configurable, like I said) as a way to reduce chunk loading lag.

import_user_oitsjustjose_95mQ commented

2016-07-28 02:23:48 +00:00

(Migrated from git.oitsjustjose.com)

How about a config option to make them run on ender pearls, but not be able to automate the piping in (like personal anchor from Railcraft)? That way when they run out of fuel a person would have to manually replace the fuel. Your way might be helpful, but I wouldn't be able to use it because I help run a server on the more bigger side, and I wouldn't be able to single handily place a chunkloader for someone when they need it.

import_user_oitsjustjose_95mQ commented

2016-07-28 02:31:02 +00:00

(Migrated from git.oitsjustjose.com)

That's be no easy feature either, since they aren't ticking tile entities right now, but that would require them to be...

I know this feature has been seen in a few other chunk loaders, but is chunk loading really that big of a concern? I understand that it causes lag, but only if what it's loading is a ridiculous build in the first place. On my server (running on a Mac Mini Server as far as hardware goes) we have them and haven't experienced any lag at our bases, with Refined Storage systems, nether pumps and RFTools excavation sites.

My last concern is that this complicates the mod itself and steps away from the original concept of it -

Persistent Bits is a very simple, no-fuel-required Chunk Loading mod.

Sort of seems like these solutions are steps in the opposite direction of the mod's "mission statement". Side note though, I've heard that RailCraft will be releasing an update soon (hopefully in the next month is my guess, but that's not been told to me by anyone), so perhaps personal anchors might be what you're looking for when the server gets to that point in lag.

That's be no easy feature either, since they aren't ticking tile entities right now, but that would require them to be... I know this feature has been seen in a few other chunk loaders, but is chunk loading really that big of a concern? I understand that it causes lag, but only if what it's loading is a ridiculous build in the first place. On my server (running on a Mac Mini Server as far as hardware goes) we have them and haven't experienced any lag at our bases, with Refined Storage systems, nether pumps and RFTools excavation sites. My last concern is that this complicates the mod itself and steps away from the original concept of it - > Persistent Bits is a very simple, no-fuel-required Chunk Loading mod. Sort of seems like these solutions are steps in the opposite direction of the mod's "mission statement". Side note though, I've heard that RailCraft will be releasing an update soon (hopefully in the next month is my guess, but that's not been told to me by anyone), so perhaps personal anchors might be what you're looking for when the server gets to that point in lag.

import_user_oitsjustjose_95mQ commented

2016-07-28 02:32:36 +00:00

(Migrated from git.oitsjustjose.com)

I understand, if you ever reconsider let me know.

import_user_oitsjustjose_95mQ (Migrated from git.oitsjustjose.com) closed this issue

2016-07-28 02:32:36 +00:00

Rows
Columns

[Suggestion] Config option for chunkloading only when player is on #4